HNC Home Page
News Business Arts & Life Sports Opinion Calendar Archive About Us
MY EYES GLAZE OVER: Click Arts&Life index for a link to a campus under stress in a series of Finals Week photos. / Photo by Brianna Mortensen

Today's word on journalism

Tuesday, December 12, 2006

Final Exam Week Edition 2: Ethnocentrism. . . .

"More powerful than all poetry,
More pervasive than all science,
More profound than all philosophy,
Are the letters of the alphabet,
Twenty-six pillars of strength,
Upon which our culture rests."

--Olof Gustaf Hugo Lagercrantz, Swedish author and critic (1911-2002) (Thanks to alert WORDster Steve Marston)


The bad taste of 'Borat'

By Ryan Pence

November 8, 2006 | I feel that someone should know to some degree what he or she is getting into. That was the case with Borat. I had seen the trailers and I had a rough understanding that this movie would be in bad taste. How bad of taste? I wasn’t quite sure, but I soon found out and when I left the movie theatre a bad “after” taste lingered in my mouth.

Story. The story is simple. Borat, a news reporter, is sent to the United States from Kazakhstan to report on the United States culture and to hopefully encourage Kazakhstan’s population to pick up on the habits and customs in the U.S. to better reform their own country. When Borat gets to the U.S., the obvious and predictable happens, major culture shock, blown completely out of proportion and hammed up to the Nth degree.

Borat starts out in New York City, but after watching an episode of Baywatch he falls in love will Pamela Anderson. So, with his producer they start out on a trek to California to find Pamela Anderson. They make various stops along the way that insure that Borat continues to insult people with his cultural indifferences.

Problems. The movie at heart is a video mockumentary about the news reporter. Borat who comes to America. Although it was meant to be in a documentary style the movie still retained a very strong story telling narrative. Because of the cross between styles the feeling of the film gets muddled a little bit and the pacing starts to drag.

A big problem with the film is surprisingly the main reason you watch the film, the cultural diversity. The movie forces upon the audience members situation after situation a blatantly offensive material, don’t worry there’s something in this movie for everyone. It almost felt like the filmmakers were trying to match the Monty Python gang punch for punch in the truly bad tasting market, for material that offends practically everyone. Unfortunately, Borat collapses under its own weight and Monty Python reins supreme with its comic wit and timing.

Bottom Line. The movie started out on strong footing introducing the audience to the bad tasting humor that should have been it truly funny. But because of its shallow Saturday Night Live skittishness it became overly drawn out and the movie started to feel long. Forty-five minutes into the movie the jokes started to draw terribly thin and monotonous, the rest were just in very bad taste. Think of this movie as just one really bad joke that you’d save your very best pity laugh on.

Rating. Rated R, for language and nudity.

Ryan’s Picks. If it’s a mockumentary you want well here are some you might want to check out.

This is Spinal Tap. A mockumentary that pretty much defined the genre ­ Spinal Tap is a UK rock band touring in the United States and we’re along for the ride. This movie is as fast paced, as it is funny. It’s an original and if you’re a fan of eighties rock where loud is cool and louder is even cooler then this is the movie for you.

Waiting for Guffman. A local community theatre director who is know for his amazingly intense productions gets wind of the possibility of a Broadway Producer, Guffman, to show up and watch an up and coming production. The community gets all excited about this prospect of taking their show to Broadway that all sense and rhythm go out the window during the preparations.

The Mighty Wind. For fans of bluegrass and folk music you don’t miss this mockumentary about the bringing together of the greatest groups of these musical styles into one big musical event. The premise is funny and the music is wonderful.

MS
RB

Copyright 1997-2005 Utah State University Department of Journalism & Communication, Logan UT 84322, (435) 797-1000
Best viewed 800 x 600.